Depending on who you learn meditation from, you’re most likely going to be taught either mantra or breath meditation. Your instructor will most likely tell you that their technique is the best. But what is the truth between mantra meditation vs. breath meditation and which one is better?
I have spent thousands of hours practicing both. I’ve also pored over the scientific literature about both.
In this article I’ll give you the definitive answer about what they are, how they’re different, and which one wins.
What are Mantra Meditation and Breath Meditation?
Mantra meditation is a practice in which you sit with your eyes closed and silently repeat a mantra in your mind continuously. The mantra is usually a meaningless sound that allows your mind to focus without thinking. The most common mantra used is “Om.”
Mantra meditation creates a rare state of mind where we are fully present but not thinking. Often thoughts will pop into the mind during meditation. When this happens, we just gently bring our thoughts back to our mantra.
Breath meditation (aka breathing meditation, aka mindfulness meditation, aka vipassana meditation, aka awareness meditation, aka insight meditation) is the practice of observing your breath. Sitting with your eyes closed, you simply observe the sensations of your breath coming in and going out.
You may put your focus on your belly expanding and contracting.
Or you may put your focus on your nose and upper lip/mustache area, sensing the nostrils flaring, the nose hairs bristling, the air brushing by your upper lip, and so on.
Another method is following the whole breath starting from it coming in the nose and down the back of your throat. Then expanding your belly and coming back out. You’ll notice the cool air coming in, the warmer air coming out, the speed and depth of your breath, etc… There are infinite subtleties to become aware of as we raise our conscious awareness.
The Benefits of Mantra and Breath Meditation
While both meditation styles have countless benefits that can improve our lives, they do have some important differences.
Benefits of Mantra Meditation
By concentrating on a mantra, this type of meditation trains our mind to focus. Our patience and attention span increase as well.
With greater focus, we become more able to focus on what really matters and set aside negative thoughts. We can overcome painful pasts and focus more on the here and now.
Mantra meditation is a deeply peaceful experience that allows our body to rest, recover, and it gives us more energy afterward.
This peaceful experience creates inner joy and also helps us boost the happiness chemicals in our brain.
With more peace, fear and stress become diminished and our creativity and confidence grow exponentially.
Benefits of Breath Meditation
Focusing on the breath comes with all the same benefits as mantra meditation. Peace, focus, concentration, joy, creativity, rest and recovery all take place.
Because you’re focusing on your breath instead of a mantra though, there are some differences.
In mantra meditation, we focus on a sound in our head. In breath, we observe reality as it truly is.
Through breath meditation, we become more aware of subtlety. We become more mindful and alert. Our minds become trained to be conscious of our breath. We tap into feeling beyond the mind.
Through this greater awareness, our wisdom and compassion grow. It is through practicing the power of observation without judgement that we become more identified with the awareness underlying our thoughts and experiences. We then see through the cloud of thoughts and are able to experience the true nature of reality.
Our once unconscious thoughts, habits and behaviors become conscious choices. By becoming more aware of ourselves and others, our intelligence grows. Afterall, observation is the foundation of all science.
As we become more mindful and conscious of ourselves, our words, thoughts and deeds become aligned with our highest intentions.
We can sense our subtlest emotional changes and we can witness them rather than being consumed by them.
To recap the mantra meditation vs. breath meditation score so far: mantra gives us focus. But breath gives us focus and awareness.
So is Mantra or Breath Meditation Better?
This is like asking whether a sunrise or a sunset is better. Breath and mantra are two sides of the same coin. Both have incredible benefits and are absolutely miraculous practices that have changed my life.
But, there are differences that I think are very important to know. While mantra meditation tends to be much easier, it can be much more challenging to consistently focus on your breath.
My Meditation Story
I spent years trying to develop a consistent, daily practice of breath meditation. I had done many meditation retreats and spent months in monasteries practicing. But as soon as I left those places, I stopped practicing daily meditation.
It was just too hard to practice breath meditation for me. My mind would wander. I’d get bored. My mind would scream, “This sucks!”
Then I took a mantra meditation course and I was blown away. It was very easy to keep my mind occupied with the mantra. The experience was pleasant and beautiful. Most importantly, it was something I could stick to.
And so I did mantra meditation for about 6 months straight without missing a day. I got all the benefits of focus, peace, joy, less stress. But I wanted more. I wanted mindfulness. As well as the heightened awareness I had experienced in retreats and monasteries. I wanted wisdom and self-awareness.
That’s when I started to try breath meditation and to my surprise, it was a pleasure as well. I have now been doing breath meditation consistently for several years and I know that this is the way.
Mantra Meditation vs. Breath Meditation: The Final Verdict
So who wins the mantra meditation vs. breath meditation debate? The answer is not one or the other. It’s both. Sometimes, I’ll still go back and do mantra meditation when my mind is too chaotic to focus on my breath. It’s much easier to focus the mind on one thought than it is to clear your head of all thoughts. This is why starting with mantra meditation is something we highly recommend. Once you’ve practiced focusing on one thought (mantra), you can easily progress to no thoughts (breath).
Like working out at the gym, all that matters is doing it consistently. You won’t maintain the benefits otherwise. For this reason, starting with mantra meditation is highly recommended for new meditators. If you wish to move on to breath meditation, you will be much more prepared to do so. If you wish to stick with mantra meditation, that is also wonderful as the benefits are numerous and profound.
To learn more about mindfulness, here is a great video you can watch.
Destress your inbox with our newsletter.